Wednesday, June 30, 2010

"Music that is so extreme, so politically incorrect and so evil."

One final contribution to Pagan Values Blogging Month . . . . .

The interview below with Nergal of Behemoth first ran in Metal As Fuck back in February of this year. Much of the interview focuses on Nergal's trial for the crime of violating Article 196 of the Polish Criminal Code which prohibits actions that "offend religious feelings." In case you missed it, the charges against Nergal were dismissed just a couple of days ago.
Behemoth's Nergal takes time out of conquering the world to speak to MAF

It would be hard to find another band that keeps up a touring schedule like Behemoth. We talk to Nergal on one of his rare days off about touring and being the clergy's Enemy Number One.

The phone crackles into life, and despite the band's on stage presence, the fires of hell are not unleashed; instead Adam Darski a.k.a Nergal answers quietly – it is morning after all.

Behemoth have just finished a gruelling tour of Europe, doing 34 shows in 35 days. Being a co-headlining tour with Devildriver meant 60-minute shows for the band.

‘It was pretty rough to be honest, it’s pretty exhausting to perform that long and it’s physically very demanding. It’s very brutal, after a few weeks you feel exhaustion and it shows. While on the bus one would get the flu, and eventually everyone would get sick, so it was pretty rough. Other than that, it was a great tour – a crossover audience because Devildriver draws a pretty different group of fans, so it was very good and beneficial to both bands.’

For anyone who has seen a live Behemoth show, it’s no surprise that each band member gives everything they have on stage. Keeping up a touring schedule that sees the band play a show almost every night leaves very little room to recover and prepare for the next venue.

‘Now that we don’t have to worry about moving our own equipment because we have a professional crew,' Darski said. 'We can now chill and do whatever we want and in most cases it’s just generally talking with friends, talking to girlfriends. Usually after a show I’ll grab a cab, go downtown, do some shopping and just chill out and try to relax. If there is a day off, I’ll usually try and watch some movies, just to keep myself entertained. Nothing in the sense of heavy partying, because that’s not what I’m into anymore. I’d rather have a decent sleep and get ready for the next show, because our shows are so demanding. It would be a huge disrespect for the people who buy tickets if I was hungover and not capable of putting on the best show I can.’

The band’s latest release Evangelion has proven to be a massive success for the band. Even though extreme metal as a genre accounts for a very small proportion of albums, the new record has made people sit up and take notice. Recently in Poland, the album was listed as the Number 1 seller in a large mainstream chain store, outselling releases from the likes of Michael Jackson and U2. Could it be more than just the pride Polish people have for Behemoth?

‘It definitely is encouraging. Seeing music that is so extreme, so politically incorrect and so evil, and it’s just selling and people dig it and people start to understand it – and I’m not talking about the masses that dig our music. The Apostasy sold 8,000 records, while Evangelion sold 15,000 in the same time period – it’s a huge step up and a great feeling.’

Poland has a very rich history of extreme metal bands. Could the fact that it is a country that counts its population of Catholics as one of the highest in the world per capita be an influencing factor on this?

‘It’s probably frustration,' Darski laughs. 'I don’t know, I’m looking out the window right, and all I see on one side is rain and grey, and I see a huge cross from the church that is 50 metres from my home. I have many reasons to be pissed off and to be unhappy, and to try and release my anger and frustration.

'It’s something in the air in Poland – there must be a reason why the Polish people and musicians try to create music that is so extreme. There isn’t much power metal here, or other genres to be honest. It’s 80% death and black metal – it’s very brutal, yeah.’

Anyone with knowledge of European history will know that Poland is a country that has endured a lot of conflict and occupation by foreign powers. It could be that the prevalence of extreme metal – music that always speaks its mind and meets controversy head on – stems from the fact that you want people to have their own opinion; you don’t want things to be forced on them by the establishment. Darski is quick to agree.

‘The way I see Behemoth is that I like to think that we can be a tool to free people. And I’m not saying that were on some sort of mission and trying to change things on a big scale – no.

'It’s cool if I get to hear or see that people who listen to Behemoth get the same feeling. If they read the lyrics and say “oh shit – I’ve never seen things like this”, they kind of open their eyes and make up their own mind. And that’s cool you know – that’s one of the main reasons we make this music – we do it for ourselves but if there’s people who can use it as a tool, it’s awesome, it’s a good feeling.’

Behemoth's popularity has not gone unnoticed by the very people that the music warns you about. Poland’s strong Catholic community – or at least the public leaders, have been very outspoken about the Behemoth stage shows and extreme music in general. By law, it is illegal to desecrate a religious icon in Poland, or perform acts that could be considered as an offence to the church.

Political organisations groups such as the All-Polish Committee for Defence Against Sects act as a watchdog and publically go after people and bands who are, in their eyes, dangerous and promote murder and Satanism. This was just one of the attacks aimed directly at Behemoth – that their music entices their fans to commit murder.

Adam Darski is not one to be afraid of controversy, and ready to speak his mind. Back in December 2007 during a concert in his home city of Gdynia, the frontman was said to have pronounced the Catholic Church as “the most murderous cult on the planet”, then called the Bible a pack of lies and tore it up on stage.

This was when the All-Polish Committee for Defence Against Sects, as well as the conservative political party Prawo i Sprawiedliwosc (Law and Justice) were required to make a very public denouncement of Behemoth. They even went so far as to call for Darski's arrest. All this despite bassist Orion (Tomasz Wróblewski) stating that the band had been doing this for two years prior. After a formal complaint was lodged with Polish authorities, the case was dismissed two months later.

One man in particular has taken a very vocal interest in Darski: Ryszard Nowak, who is the leader of the All-Polish Committee for Defense Against Sects. After calling Nergal a criminal in a public interview, though, it seems that the Babylonian god from whom Darski takes his stage name had had enough. He took Nowak to court over his statements and won. The court ruled that Nowak had to make a public apology for his remarks, and pay Darski an undisclosed sum – one which he directed be made to a local dog shelter. It must have been a surprise for Darski when the courts ruled in his favour.

‘It was surprising on one hand, but you know what, the whole thing with Ryszard Nowak – the way I see it, and the way the majority of people who use their brains,' DArski laughs, 'see it. It is no longer a clash of different religious sides – it’s not a religious conflict – it’s a war between stupidity and narrow mindedness and backwards thinking against the opposite. Obviously I represent the open mindedness and liberation. So that’s the way the people saw that, that I’m not necessarily satanic, they don’t like the music – but I’m right.' He laughs again. 'You know, things change and I think that were on the right track to get to the right spot.’

This wasn’t the end of the attack on Behemoth however, with the case being reopened (this time by Prawo i Sprawiedliwosc) in January of this year, to investigate whether the tearing up of a bible constitutes a crime.

Darski recently won the Gdansk Young Culture Creators award, which recognises young people for their contribution to a country’s culture - a far cry from the allegations that keep following Behemoth.

‘It’s funny – it’s a big contradiction. On one hand there’s all these accusations of us being Public Enemy Number 1, we should be prison, we should be stabbed and burned. And then on the other hand we are winning everything on the way. It’s crazy and awesome at the same time. On one hand we are doing something very artistic and it’s always recognised and respected by a renowned group of people – the Behemoth fans. And now it seems like the big people in the mainstream media recognise that there is a band that does something for this country and it's good and quality – and it's art, and it's recognised in the world. And that’s a good feeling; it’s something that is in a way humorous.

'In one of the biggest polish magazines, The Activist, we picked up the award for the best band, and we picked up awards with all these big pop artists. It’s awesome, it’s good.’

Extreme metal is not what anyone outside the metal fanbase would consider a popular genre, yet this clearly shows that the talent in creating the music is being recognised for its artistic merit, despite the fact that it is not considered mainstream.

‘I see this as a very positive thing, and it seems to be a very European way of thinking. People’s minds are open to hearing new stuff, things they are not used to.’

Fans of Behemoth know that their live shows are a very intense experience. The band has always been known for their elaborate stage costumes and make up – and bucking the trend of where some black metal musicians take their corpsepaint make up skills to comedic levels – sometimes intentionally and other times not.

During the interview, Darski comes across as a quietly spoken person, a far cry from the brutal visage of Nergal (named after a Babylonian god) on stage. If a Behemoth show doesn’t leave you with the hair on your neck standing up, you may want to check your pulse rate to see if you are alive.

It must be a difficult task to separate the beast Nergal from Adam Darski and go back to everyday life, considering the punishing tour schedules.

‘Not really,' Darski laughs. 'People can’t see me smiling a lot. When I’m on stage, wearing the mask and makeup – I can’t stop laughing and smiling when I see the energy and see the people going completely crazy for us. I think wow, that’s awesome, it’s killer and I just can’t stop smiling.

'It’s not like there is someone completely different there, but then again it’s like two different sides of one coin – it’s still one coin. It’s just a different attitude.’

Something not widely known, at least not outside the Polish gossip press, is Darski’s relationship with Polish pop star Doda (Dorota Rabaczewska). It may seem odd that the leader of what is arguably one of the biggest extreme metal bands and enemy number one for religious conservatives is dating a pop star. What it has led to, however, is the fact that even regular weekly press, normally full of articles and badly photoshopped images of actors and starlets, now features photos of the frontman. Darski is quick to dismiss the notion.

‘You know... it is what it is, I don’t really care about it. I’m in it for my relationship, I’m not in it for the public relations – it is great PR, but I just don’t analyse it.’

Finishing the European tour in late December, the band only had a few weeks to relax before starting a new tour of the US in January, to be followed by shows in Greece and Turkey in March. Darski happily reveals that Australian fans are about to be treated to another round of Behemoth after that – a (recently announced) combined tour with Goatwhore and Job for a Cowboy.

Behemoth are also confirmed for the Summer Breeze 2010 festival in Germany, and are doing a 12-week festival tour, with both festival and side shows. Playing big festivals, in front of tens of thousands of fans must be a very different feeling to playing a club gig with a more intimate setting.

‘Obviously it is different, it’s more open – it’s crazier in many ways. I enjoy both though. To me though, a club with a 1,000-person capacity totally packed and sold out – that is the best.’

Being involved in a genre like extreme metal would lead people to believe that most musicians would only listen to metal. Darski reveals that it is not only pounding drum blasts and piercing guitars that help him enjoy his days.

‘Oh wow, I listen to a variety of stuff that I enjoy like electro new wave gothic stuff which is awesome. I don’t think most Behemoth would dig it,' he laughs, 'because it's odd stuff. The new Alice In Chains is fucking awesome and other bands like Catharsis are absolutely amazing. So, yeah, there’s definitely a lot of killer metal music too.’

A constant touring schedule means Behemoth gets to share the stage with many bands. You could play the six degrees of separation game with Behemoth and come up with almost every extreme and heavy metal band in the world.

‘We’ve toured with most of the big bands, but we still haven’t played with Metallica. If one day we stand on the same stage as Metallica it would be a huge thing for us,' Darski laughs.

Coming to the end of the interview, Darski has a simple message for the Aussie fans.

‘I know the new album is out on Riot, I just hope you all grab a copy and enjoy the record. I can’t wait to come back; I have nothing but great memories from Australia. Come down to the show if you have a chance.’

We wouldn’t miss it for anything.

"We're not sinners, we're just disconnected from the Divine Life-Force." (My contribution to Pagan Values Blogging Month)

"Go see Avatar: the most demonic, Satanic film I've ever seen .... See, in that movie it is a completely false ideology, it is a sermon preached. It is the most popular movie ever made. It tells you ... that we're not sinners, we're just disconnected from the Divine Life-Force. Just classic, classic, classic Paganism. That human beings are to connect, literally, with trees and animals and beasts and birds -- and that there's this spiritual connection that we're all a part of, and we're all part of the Divine. It presents a false mediator with a witch. It presents false worship of created things rather than the creator god. It's the absolute antithesis of Romans 1:25"
[Pastor Mark Driscoll, of Mars Hill Church]
They exchanged the truth of God for a lie, and worshiped and served created things rather than the Creator—who is forever praised. Amen.
[Romans, 1:25]

The Plato Code?

Jay Kennedy (a visiting scholar at the University of Manchester) has produced a detailed study of what he claims are regular, objectively quantifiable, "musical" patterns in the works of Plato. These mathematical patterns, according to Kennedy, are strongly Pythagorean. A quick look at Kennedy's own "Introduction for Scholars" to his work justifies, in my opinion, taking him and his work seriously.

Although there are some real problems (surprise!) with how Kennedy's research is being hyped in the media, there are some very positive aspects to what he is up to. The important thing to remember, however, is that Kennedy's "discovery", in fact, merely confirms the predominant view of Plato and his philosophy that held sway for well over 20 centuries, and which was only very recently replaced with a new "scholarly consensus".

Here is what Kennedy has to say in his own words:
The distance between 'neo-Platonism' and Platonism has been steadily diminishing since the work of Dodds. This work implies that the reports among Plato students that he was a Pythagorean in some strong sense were correct. This reaffirms the views among some neo-Pythagoreans and neo-Platonists. How is the history of the reception of Plato now altered?

Monday, June 28, 2010

Hinduism: "The best surviving of the great Pagan traditions"

David Frawley is founder and director of the American Insitute of Vedic Studies. Though American born, in India he is recognized not only as a Vedacharya (Vedic teacher), but also as a Vaidya (Ayurvedic doctor and teacher), Jyotishi (Vedic astrologer), Puranic (Vedic historian), a Hindu acharya (Hindu religious teacher) and a Yogi.

Dr. Frawley is the author of numerous books, including Tantric Yoga and the Wisdom Goddesses (a book on the Hindu Goddesses known as the Mahavidyas), Awaken Bharata: A Call For India's Rebirth, and How I Became a Hindu.

Frawley's vision of Hinduism is expansive and inclusive while being solidly rooted in Vedic tradition. He is one of the most articulate proponents of the view that Hinduism and Paganism share a very real and deep kinship. The following is from a new essay by Dr. Frawley: A Universal Vision: Hinduism's Path to Unity (just published online at the website -- go to the link to read the whole thing!):
Hinduism is probably the oldest continually practiced religious and spiritual tradition on the planet, with its roots going back over 5,000 years. In fact Hinduism has no specific point of origin or end. The basis of Hinduism can be found not in a particular prophet or prophets or in a single book but in the eternal, in the cosmic mind itself, accepting a variety of great teachers and teachings over the long course of time and the different types of human cultures. Hinduism has never rejected any aspect of human religious aspiration, whether it is the use of images, a variety of rituals, or many techniques and approaches to meditation.

Hinduism is the third largest of the world's major religions, with over a billion adherents worldwide. It is the largest of the non-biblical traditions. It is the largest of the pagan traditions and the best surviving of the great pagan traditions that once dominated the world and traces of which remain everywhere. It is the largest of the native or indigenous traditions being rooted in the land and life of its peoples. Hinduism is firmly rooted in nature and honors all aspects of the natural world as sacred. Its holy places are not simply sites of important human religious activity but sacred mountains, rivers, rocks, trees, and flowers.

Yet perhaps most importantly Hinduism is the largest of the world's ‘pluralistic' traditions. It does not emphasize one formulation of divinity, one prophet or savior, or one holy book for all. It honors a variety of great gurus and their various books and teachings. Under its vast scope it can embrace a great variety of religious views and practices. This makes Hinduism the largest of the world's non-proselytizing religions. Hinduism does not seek to convert the world to a single belief but holds that we should honor the unique divine expression in each person and in each culture. It gives people the freedom to follow whatever spiritual path they find valuable. Hinduism can even accept atheists as part of its honoring of freedom of thought and inquiry.

For more on the relationship between Hinduism and Paganism see: Hindus and Pagans: "A Return to the Time of the Gods".

Blasphemy Case Against Nergal "Dismissed"

According to "Gdynia District Court on Monday dismissed the case" against Adam Darski, better known to the world as Nergal, frontman for the extreme metal band Behemoth.

"The court held that there was no crime," according to the report. However, the prosecutor "announced an appeal against that decision." Attorneys for Ryszard Nowak, chief cook and head bottle washer of the Polish National Committee for Defense Against Sects, announced that the appeal would be filed as soon as the Court provides "written reasons for its decision" to dismiss the case.

The case stems from a September 2007 Behemoth concert in the city of Gdynia, during which Nergal announced that "the Catholic Church is the most murderous sect in history". After this, Darski then publicly tore up a copy of the Bible, and distributed the fragments to the audience, requesting that these be burned.

For background on this case (and related cases, including that of Darski's fiance Doda Elektroda) see the earlier post on "Sex, Religion, Art, Music & Freedom of Expression in Poland".

Israelis barred from Pride events

In Madrid, an Israeli singer's concert, scheduled as part of that city's July 3rd Pride events, has been cancelled. The singer in question is Dana International, an Israeli transgender singer who won the 1998 Eurovision song contest. It was also announced that the Israeli contingent would be barred from the Madrid Pride Parade.

The president of Spain's Federation of Lesbians, Gays, Transexuals and Bisexuals linked these moves to the Israeli response to the Gaza "peace flotilla": "After what has happened, it seemed barbaric to us as human rights campaigners to have Israelis take part."

Israel passed comprehensive legislation banning all discrimination against LGBT people over two decades ago. Gays serve openly in the Israeli military. On the other hand, legal protections for LGBT people are non-existent in the Palestinian territories. There are a few Palestinian LGBT rights groups, but these are headquartered in Israel, because no such organization can openly function in either Gaza or the West Bank.

In a related story, on June 8th, two Israeli business men were injured while attending a conference at the Autonomous University of Madrid. A group of demonstrators broke into the location of the conference, at which many Israelis were participants, chanting "Murderers!!". As conference participants were being escorted away by police they were pelted with stones, resulting in injuries to two Israelis. The police stated that they believed "most of the rioters were Muslims."

Arab-Israeli Tensions Spill Over to Pride Celebrations
Israeli float banned from Madrid's Gay Pride Parade
Michael Lucas on Madrid’s Bad Pride
Jerusalem Open House
Israel, Palestine, Gays
Palestinian Gay Runaways Survive on Israeli Streets
Our country is safe for Israelis despite Madrid attack
Spain: Pro-Palestinian activists attack Israeli businessmen

Sunday, June 27, 2010

UPDATE: July 10th date set by European Values Study

According to the website of the European Values Study:

"The fieldwork of the European Values Study 2008 is now completed. A first release of the data to the general public will be ready on July 10th, 2010."

As I mentioned earlier I am especially eager to see the most results for how the belief in reincarnation is holding up in Europe.

Dr. Erlendur Haraldsson (Professor Emeritus University of Iceland) published a fascinating study in 2006 based largely on past European Values Study data: "Popular psychology, belief in life after death and reincarnation" (click here to download the pdf). Here's the abstract of that paper:
The European Values Survey explores national differences and similarities, also regarding religious beliefs which express popular assumptions regarding the nature of man and the ontological status of consciousness. These views differ radically from the dominant scientific view, also in academic psychology. The Nordic countries vary considerably in their beliefs in life after death and reincarnation with half of the respondents believing in life after death, and 43 percent of these believing in reincarnation which also goes against established views of the Christian Church. This shows independence from scientific as well as religious authorities. Is it a remnant of pre-Christian beliefs, due to exposure to Buddhist and Hindu concepts, or a sign of original independent thinking? Half a century of anti-religious regimes in Eastern Europe seems to have had no major effect on beliefs about personal survival, and the European Values Survey shows a widespread belief in reincarnation.

One in five Dutch teachers avoid the Holocaust

"A fifth of history teachers in the four major Dutch cities have had to deal with not being able to or rarely bringing up the Holocaust because Muslim students in particular have difficulties with it."

This is according to a survey conducted by Elsevier magazine and ResearchNed (an independent social sciences research institute).

The story was originally reported at (in Dutch), and an English translation is available at the Islam in Europe website.

Saturday, June 26, 2010

Doda in Kluczbork: "Those Who Expected Scandal Were Not Disappointed"

According to media reports, Polish singer Doda (already facing a possible two year prison sentence under Poland's anti-blasphemy laws) arrived for her Friday night concert in the town of Kluczbork "w klatce, ubrana w futurystyczny mundurek, odsłaniający pół piersi i całe pośladki" ("in a cage, dressed in a futuristic uniform, revealing half of breast and whole buttocks.")

After she finished her opening number, Doda left the stage and the voice of Pope John Paul II boomed out over the sound system:

"My dear young friends, I am so glad that you are here tonight."

After this the words: "I am psycho" (in English) and "I am a freak" ("Jestem świrem" in Polish) were flashed on the giant screens on either side of the stage.

Then Doda reappeared on stage dressed as a witch to sing her next song.

According to Nowa Tribuna Opolska, "Ci, którzy oczekiwali skandalizującego zachowania, nie zawiedli się. Na koncercie są tysiące ludzi." ("Those who were expecting scandalous behavior were not disappointed.")

A video of part of the performance has already been uploaded to youtube:

Thursday, June 24, 2010

"Juden Raus": Muslim Teenagers Stone Jews In Hanover

From Ha'aretz:
Muslim youths in Germany throw stones at Jewish street performers
By Ofer Aderet

BERLIN - Jewish dancers staging a street performance in Hanover, Germany were attacked by a group of stone-throwing Muslim youths, German police said yesterday.

According to police, the assailants were young people of Lebanese, Palestinian and Iranian origin. They reportedly threw stones at the dancers and taunted them by yelling phrases like "Juden raus" ("Jews out" ). The performance had to be stopped, and two of the attackers - aged 14 and 19 - were arrested.

Hanover Mayor Stephan Weil described the incident as "unacceptable." Aygul Ozkan, social affairs and integration minister for the local government of Lower Saxony, said she was seriously concerned by the incident. Ozkan last year became the first minister of Turkish-Muslim origin to be appointed in Germany.

Charlotte Knobloch, chair of the Central Council of Jews in Germany, said the incident posed a new social challenge to Germany. "I'm saddened this anti-Semitic attack involved children and young people," she said.

Police noted this was the first anti-Semitic incident in Hanover this year to have been committed by someone other that right-wing extremists.

Juliane Wetzel, of the Bundestag committee against anti-Semitism, said she was not surprised by the incident. "Jews in Germany have faced violent attacks for years, especially in light of the conflict in the Middle East," she said.
A more detailed account of this sickening incident can be found in an article at the Hannoversche Algemeine. That's auf Deutsch -- a good English translation can be found at the Islam in Europe website here.

[The photo in this post was originally taken at a Jewish cemetery in Herrlisheim, eastern France in April, 2004. It is from Vazelines' photo gallery at "picasa". Here is a direct link to the photo.]

Wednesday, June 23, 2010

Doda: "Forbidden Fruit Tastes Better"

It almost seems as if Poland's infamous National Committee for Defense Against Sects (a right-wing Catholic group) is trying to make Doda (Dorota Rabczewska) even more famous than she already is.

The illustrious president of this "Committee", Ryszard Nowak, keeps demanding cancelation of Doda's concerts on the grounds that she is liable to commit the criminal act of blasphemy while she is on stage. Every time Nowak opens his mouth, more Doda tickets are sold.

In a statement released this Monday, Rabczewska herself predicted that Nowak's efforts will continue to add to the success of her current Rock'n'Roll Palace Tour because "Zakazany owoc smakuje lepiej", which translates to "forbidden fruit tastes better."

The Polish singer, who came in second in the 2009 MTV Music Awards Best European Act competition, also said that the publicity resulting from the accusations that she is "scandalous" and "blasphemous" has been "bezcenna" ("priceless").

Controversy and censorship are not new to Doda, who was forced to change two lines from her song "Diamond Bitch" when she competed at the Superjedynki competition in June 2008, at which she won "Artist of the Year." (Scroll down for the lyrics, in both Polish and English, and see if you can guess which lines were censored).

Doda's St. Johns' Night concert in Tomaszów Lubelski this evening (Wed. June 23) went ahead as scheduled, and this weekend she is headlining at the Kluczbork Days Festival in the town of Kluczbork, despite the continued protests of Nowak and his "Committee."

"Diamond Bitch" lyrics
Gdy tylko ruszę tyłkiem, Once the moves booty,
lecisz niczym pies. fly like a dog.
Znów całą noc marzyłeś, Again, all night long dreamed of,
żeby móc powąchać mnie. to be able to sniff me.
Wiem jak chcesz robić to, I know how you do it,
tylko ja tą rozkosz dam! I only give this delight!

Moje uda rozchylone, My thighs parted,
moje piersi tak cię podniecają! my breasts so you excited!
Moje usta rozpalone, My mouth is burning,
moje biodra już Ci spać nie dają! my hips now you can not sleep!

Gdy było nam źle starałeś się- When we were bad, you tried to
nosiłeś smycz z diamentami! nosiłeś leash from the diamond!
Stało się tak, że na mój znak It happened so that my sign
zjawił się ktoś między nami! someone came between us!

Gdy pani ci pozwoli, When you you will,
wyliżesz grzecznie ją. lick it politely.
Lubisz jak cię dotyka! Do you like how you touch!
Wyuzdana jestem bo, Because I'm promiscuous,
wiem jak chcesz robić to, I know how you do it,
tylko ja tą rozkosz dam! I only give this delight!

Moje uda rozchylone, My thighs parted,
moje piersi tak cię podniecają! my breasts so you excited!
Moje usta rozpalone, My mouth is burning,
moje biodra już Ci spać nie dają! my hips now you can not sleep!

Gdy było nam źle starałeś się- When we were bad, you tried to
nosiłeś smycz z diamentami! nosiłeś leash with diamonds!
Stało się tak, że na mój znak It happened so that my sign
zjawił się ktoś między nami! someone came between us!

Gdy prosisz mnie When you ask me
o jeszcze raz, tracisz mój czas! here again, you lose my time!
Gdy prosisz o When you ask for
ten jeden dzień, znów męczysz mnie! This one day, wearied me again!

Moje uda rozchylone, My thighs parted,
moje piersi tak cię podniecają! my breasts so you excited!
Moje usta rozpalone, My mouth is burning,
moje biodra już Ci spać nie dają! my hips now you can not sleep!

Gdy było nam źle starałeś się- When we were bad, you tried to
nosiłeś smycz z diamentami! nosiłeś leash with diamonds!
Stało się tak, że na mój znak It happened so that my sign
zjawił się ktoś między nami! someone came between us!

Moje uda rozchylone, My thighs parted,
moje piersi tak cię podniecają! my breasts so you excited!
Moje usta rozpalone, My mouth is burning,
moje biodra już Ci spać nie dają! my hips now you can not sleep!

Gdy było nam źle starałeś się- When we were bad, you tried to
nosiłeś smycz z diamentami! nosiłeś leash with diamonds!
Stało się tak, że na mój znak It happened so that my sign
zjawił się ktoś między nami! someone came between us!

Doda Elektroda & the Battle of Tomaszów Lubelski

Noc Świętojańska (St John's Night) is the traditional Polish celebration of Midsummer (the Summer Solstice, more or less). But this year the holiday has a new name: Noc Świętojańska z Dodą. That means "St. John's Night of Doda."

That's because Polish pop-music phenomenon Dorota Rabczewska, (aka Doda Elektroda or simply Doda), is the headliner for a "St. Johns' Night" concert this evening in Tomaszów Lubelski, a small Polish town previously known primarily as the sight of one of the major battles in the infamous joint Nazi-Soviet invasion of Poland in 1939.

Doda is currently under indictment for violating Article 196 of the Polish Criminal Code which prohibits "offending religious feelings." The charges stem from a television interview the singer gave in 2009 in which she stated that, in her opinion, the Bible is not a reliable source of accurate information, and she also speculated that some of those who wrote the Bible did so under the influence of mind-altering drugs.

Ryszard Nowak, the head of the right-wing ultra-Catholic (and Orwellianly named) National Committee for Defense Against Sects, had demanded that the city of Tomaszów Lubelski cancel the concert. The city has refused to do so, and the obsessivly litigious Nowak has warned that if Doda says anything "blasphemous" during the concert that he intends to take legal action against the town's mayor, Ryszard Sobczuk.

Very little information about all this is available in English. But if you do a google search on "bluźnierczej Dody" (without the quotes) and then use google translate, you can get a good idea of what is going on. In Polish "bluźnierczej" means "blasphemous".

Monday, June 21, 2010

Two More "Hate Speech" Cases Rearing Their Ugly Heads In Europe

Jesper Langballe (Denmark) and Bruce Bawer (Norway) have now entered the ranks of Europe's growing population of coal-mine dwelling small passarine birds of the genus Serinus in the finch family. That is to say, their right to freedom of speech is being attacked because they have chosen to exercise that right to criticize religious beliefs and practices they disagree with.

Langballe is a leading member of one of the parties making up the current governing coalition in Denmark. Last week the Danish parliament voted to strip Langballe of his immunity, as a member of Parliament, from being prosecuted for the crime of having written an editorial criticizing Islam for it's poor record with respect to women's rights.

Bawer is an American born writer, poet and literary critic who has lived in Oslo for over a decade. Last week Bawer announced that he had recently discovered that the Royal Norwegian Ministry of Children, Equality, and Social Inclusion had commissioned a report that specifically attacks Bawer for promoting "Islamophobia."

Langballe and Bawer are in good, or at least very interesting, company, including:

Geert Wilders (Netherlands)
Rokku Abdilla and Anthony Neilson (Malta)
Javier Krahe (Spain)
Oriana Fallaci (France and Italy)
Dorota Nieznalska, Jerzy Urban, Adam Darski, and Dorota Rabczewska (Poland)

It should be noted that the cases in Malta, Spain and Poland involve individuals who criticized, or were accused of "insulting" or "offending", the Roman Catholic Church, not Islam.

And there are also at least two notable cases in the European Diaspora as well: those of Mark Steyn and Ezra Levant in Canada, and Danny Nalliah in Australia.

To put things into properly ironic context, just one month ago, on May 20, the European Parliament passed a resolution calling upon the nation of Pakistan:
to carry out a “thoroughgoing review” of its blasphemy laws because they were “open to misuse.” It also condemned the “contradiction” between the Pakistani government’s commitment to religious freedom and its “leading role” in the Organisation of the Islamic Conference in seeking the UN’s condemnation of “defamation of religion.”
[from: Blasphemy laws - European Parliament asked to be consistent about blasphemy article at Reporters Without Borders website]

Sunday, June 20, 2010

Human Rights Watch on "Children Accused of Sorcery" in DR Congo

Below are two sections of the April 2006 report by Human Rights Watch titled "What Future? Street Children in the Democratic Republic of the Congo." First is the Summary of the report, followed by the section on "Factors pushing children onto the streets" which includes a major subsection on "Children accused of sorcery." The entire report can be read online here, and is also available for download in pdf format. This post is part of a series on The Christian Roots of the "Witch Children" Phenomenon in Africa.


I. Summary

Our worry is this, what will become of these kids tomorrow? Thousands of children living on the streets with no supervision, no education, no love or care, accustomed to daily violence and abuse. What future for these children and for our country?
—Street child educator in Lubumbashi
After my parents died, I moved in with my uncle. But things were bad at his home. He was often drunk and would beat me. He took my parents things but he wouldn’t take care of me. I began spending more and more time in the streets.
—Street boy in Kinshasa
The [military] police bother us at night. They ask for money, and if we have none, they threaten us with arrest and beat us.
—Street boy in Goma

Tens of thousands of children living on the streets of Kinshasa and other cities of the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) suffer extreme hardship and exposure to daily violence. Turned out of their homes and without family care and support, they are victims of physical, sexual and emotional abuse. With no secure access to food, shelter, or other basic needs, they are exploited by adults, including law enforcement personnel, who use them for illegal activities to the detriment of their health and welfare and in violation of their basic human rights. The government of the DRC has failed to meet its obligations to protect these children from abuses committed by its own police and military forces and by private actors. Of particular concern is the deliberate and opportunistic recruitment of street children to participate in political demonstrations with the intention of provoking public disorder, events in which dozens of street children have been killed or wounded. During the upcoming national elections tentatively scheduled for June 18, 2006, the government must protect street children from political manipulation. The government in power after the 2006 elections must begin to comprehensively address the many other abuses committed against street children.

This report is based on interviews with more than fifty street children––children who might not necessarily be without families, but who live without meaningful protection, supervision, or direction from responsible adults. Although many children spend some time in the streets, the term “street child” is used here to refer to children for whom the street, more than any family, residence or institution, has become their real home.

Many street children live in fear of the very state forces charged to protect them. The testimonies from children we interviewed revealed a common pattern of routine abuse by police, soldiers, and members of the military police. These figures of authority approach street children, often at night, and demand their money or articles of clothing, threatening them with their fists, boots and batons. One fourteen-year-old boy, who sleeps with his friends in empty kiosks near a Goma market, told us, “We are regularly harassed by the military police. In the evenings, they come to where we are sleeping and take whatever they can from us. We are chased and if caught, they beat us with their fists or a piece of wood.” In addition to physical violence, police and soldiers forcibly rape or sexually assault street girls. Girls can also be approached by soldiers or police officers who offer them small amounts of money in exchange for sex. The police use street children to spy on suspected criminals, provide decoys in police operations, and in some instances recruit them to participate in robberies of stores and homes. Children told us that they have no choice but to comply with whatever law enforcement personnel demand or risk further abuse and harassment.

The police routinely arrest street children when crimes are committed in areas where they are known to gather. While it is true that street children are sometimes involved in crimes, the police often hold them collectively responsible for crimes or knowledgeable about the events or the perpetrators. During interrogations, the police regularly beat children with their fists, batons, belts, or pieces of rubber to elicit a confession or information about a crime. Officials in the Ministry of the Interior also periodically order general roundups of street children under a colonial-era law that forbids vagrancy or begging by minors. Large groups of children, guilty of nothing more than homelessness, are apprehended and held in overcrowded and unsanitary police lockups. Once in detention, children are often kept together with adult criminals and receive little or no food or medical attention. They are rarely charged with crimes, but instead are released back to the streets after several days or weeks, in part because the state has no alternatives to prison or the street for vagrant children.

Civilians also exploit street children. They employ children as porters, vendors, cleaners, or laborers in homes and stores, often paying them little money for long hours and physically demanding work. Some street children told us that they are used by adults to work in hazardous or illegal labor, such as mining, prostitution, or selling drugs and alcohol. Street children also report that many adults, like the police, taunt them, beat them, and chase them from places where they congregate. The youngest street children we interviewed said that some of the worst treatment comes from older street boys and men. Both boys and girls are survivors of rape and sexual assault perpetrated by older street boys and men; some girls are the survivors of brutal gang rapes. Street children told us that the police fail to investigate these crimes or offer protection from abusive adults.

Conflict, internal displacement, unemployment, poverty, disease, the prohibitive cost of education, and myriad other factors have all contributed to the growing number of children living and working on the streets in the DRC. Two additional and interrelated factors, however, are helping to fuel the increasing numbers of street children: the abuse and abandonment of children accused of sorcery, and the impact of HIV/AIDS on families and children affected by or infected with the virus.

Boys and girls accused of sorcery are often physically and emotionally abused, segregated from other children, pulled out of school, and denied physical contact with other family members. Parents, guardians, or older siblings may accuse a child of engaging in sorcery or being “possessed” due to sickness or death in the family, loss of a steady income or a job, or perceived abnormal behavior in the child. In our interviews, we found that children who were orphaned and cared for by extended family members or children whose mothers or fathers had remarried were far more likely to be accused than those living with both their biological parents. Some accused children were forced out of their homes; others fled when the abuse became intolerable.

Many accused children are brought before pastors, cult leaders, or self-proclaimed “prophets” and forced to undergo often lengthy “deliverance” ceremonies in an attempt to rid them of “possession.” Deliverance ceremonies can take place in “churches of revival” (églises de réveil) found throughout Kinshasa and Mbuji-Mayi and rapidly spreading to other cities. The growth in the number of new churches of revival is both a consequence of child sorcery accusations and a cause of new allegations; more than 2,000 churches practice deliverance in Kinshasa alone. Some prophets who run these churches have gained celebrity-like status, drawing in hundreds of worshipers in lucrative Sunday services because of their famed “success” in child exorcism ceremonies. This popularity rewards them for their often brutal treatment of children. Children who undergo deliverance rituals are sequestered inside churches anywhere from a few hours to several days or weeks. Many are denied food and water to encourage them to confess to practicing witchcraft. In the worst cases, children are beaten, whipped, or given purgatives, to coerce a confession. One twelve-year-old street boy in Kinshasa, held in a church with dozens of other children, said, “We were not allowed to eat or drink for three days. On the fourth day, the prophet held our hands over a candle, to get us to confess. So, I accepted the accusations and the abuse ended. Those who did not accept were threatened with a whip.” After the ceremonies, children who do not confess are often sent away from their homes. Even children who do confess may be subjected to future abuse and abandonment. Despite the prevalence and seriousness of abuses stemming from accusations of sorcery in homes and churches, and despite the new constitution’s prohibition of accusations of child sorcery, the state has failed to stop the violence. In fact, the government has failed even to investigate the most serious cases of abuse by parents or prophets and bring those responsible for the mistreatment of children to justice.

The growing number of street children and increases in accusations of sorcery are strongly correlated with the spread of HIV/AIDS in the DRC. The estimated national HIV/AIDS prevalence rate is 4.2 percent, lower than many countries in eastern and southern Africa, but resulting in approximately one million Congolese children orphaned by the epidemic. The impact of the disease has been enormous and has strained the fabric of communities and families. Children infected and affected by AIDS face stigma and discrimination inside and outside their homes. They are likely be pulled from school to care for sick family members or to find work in the streets to support their families, leaving them susceptible to abuse and exploitation. Some children who have lost one or both parents to the disease are taken in by the extended family, only to be abused or neglected and end up on the street. Worse still is the link between accusations of sorcery and the epidemic. Several street children we interviewed whose parents had died of AIDS were blamed by family members for the deaths, told that they had transmitted the disease to their parents through sorcery. These children were physically and emotionally abused, thrown out of their homes, and had been denied their right to inherit their parent’s property and valuables, including the smallest mementos to recall their parents. Even children who are themselves HIV-positive and in desperate need of medical care and protection are targets of accusations, abuse, and abandonment. HIV/AIDS awareness and prevention campaigns stressing ABC (Abstinence, Be faithful, and use Condoms) have to date failed to refute the commonly held view that HIV can be transmitted through sorcery and have done nothing to address the abuses experienced by children or to reduce their vulnerability.

In the first half of 2006, the DRC will face important democratic national elections. Political party leaders and their followers, opposed to the electoral process or the final results, may again attempt to recruit street children to intimidate voters, disrupt the elections, or contest the outcome. Street children who in past years were paid to join the ranks of party loyalists and march in political rallies and demonstrations faced sometimes brutal consequences. In several cities in the DRC in June 2005, troops and police killed or wounded scores of demonstrators, including street children, who were recruited to protest the extension of the transitional government’s mandate. In the worst example to date, at least twenty street children associated with one political party were massacred by angry civilians in Mbuji-Mayi in September 2004, while the police and the military largely failed to intervene. In the coming months there is a risk that street children, as in the past, will once again be manipulated, wounded or killed in political unrest. The Congolese government must protect these children from exploitation and, together with support from the international community, halt the abuse of street children and begin to address the underlying causes and violence that drive thousands of children into the streets each year.


VI. Factors Pushing Children into the Streets

An ever increasing number of children live and work in the streets of the DRC. Although exact numbers are unknown, child protection activists estimate that the number of street children in Kinshasa and other urban areas has doubled in the last ten years. They have identified multiple and sometimes inter-related causes to explain the increase. The two successive civil wars, one that began in 1996, the other in 1998, left more than 3.5 million Congolese civilians dead and has devastated the country. Some children living on the streets lost parents in the war––either directly in the conflict or due to hunger or disease––or were separated from them while fleeing violence, particularly in the war-ravaged east of the country. Entrenched poverty made worse due to the fighting has taken an equally heavy toll on Congolese families. Unable to feed their children, much less pay for their education, some parents send their children out into the streets to beg or look for work, or parents abandon their children when, faced with unemployment, they leave their homes in search of work in other regions or countries. Men and women who become single parents due to divorce, separation, or the death of a spouse often increase the vulnerability of their children to violence and abandonment when they re-marry. In many cases, a recently wedded second wife or husband does not want to care for children from a previous marriage, and the children are neglected or sent away. In the past, children not cared for by their parents would be taken in by extended family members. But some families, already struggling to care for their own children, are unwilling or unable to take on the additional burden of more children.

Violence in the Home

Street children we interviewed gave graphic descriptions of physical abuse at home, in some cases so severe that they had left because of it. Stepmothers or stepfathers were often the perpetrators of the abuse, giving differing treatment (including harsh punishment) to children from former marriages as compared to their own biological children. In interviews in Lubumbashi and Mbuji-Mayi, judges told us that physical abuse of children in the home is common in many Congolese families, but cases of child abuse and neglect rarely enter the court system. They reported that under Congolese law, a parent can be charged and judged responsible if a child is severely beaten but neither parents nor children generally report the abuse to the police. Rather, neighbors or extended family members will try to intervene to settle family disturbances. Emphasis in most family disputes is placed on reconciliation not retribution, in part because the state has no facilities to take children who are abused or abandoned into care.111

Jacques was eight years old when his parents divorced. He lived with his father in Lubumbashi after his mother left for Kinshasa. Soon after the divorce, his father remarried a woman who had several children from a previous marriage. He told us that not long after moving in with the family, his stepmother began giving him more and more work to do around the home. He was responsible for washing all the clothes and fetching water, while her own children were exempt from domestic chores. He said that she would often hit him and in some cases whipped him when his father was not around, telling him he was not wanted in their home. Although he complained to his father, the situation did not improve. Jacques left home because of the abuse when he was ten years old.112

Fifteen-year-old Aaron was born and grew up in Limete commune in Kinshasa. His mother died of complications from AIDS in 1999, and soon after her death his father re-married. He told us that his stepmother mistreated him from the very beginning, favoring her own children from her first marriage. She gave him less food than her own children, and when they watched television he was made to leave the room. She beat him for the smallest infraction, sometimes with her hands, sometimes with the handle of a broom, and one time, she slammed his hands in a door. Aaron complained to his father, but he was often not at home. His father eventually became sick, was hospitalized, and later died, presumably also from AIDS. During the time of his father’s illness, his stepmother blamed Aaron for the sickness and made him sleep outside the house. After his funeral, she chased him from their home.113

Street boys playing at a center for children in Kinshasa. © 2005 Marcus Bleasdale

Isaac lost his father during the war and his mother remarried after moving the family to Goma in the late 1990s. Using the term “uncle” to refer to his stepfather, he said:

My uncle never accepted me in their home. He would pick on me in front of the other children and say terrible things about my father. He refused to pay my school fees and instead would lock me in the house during the day when the other kids were at school. He would buy clothes and shoes for the other children, but never for me. When the abuse became too much, I finally decided to leave.114

Children Accused of Sorcery

Related to the increase in the number of children on the streets are accusations that children, through sorcery, are responsible for the various economic and social problems that plague families. Accused children throughout the DRC, but particularly in Kinshasa and Mbuji-Mayi, can be physically and verbally abused, neglected, and sometimes abandoned by their families. Individuals who work with children in Kinshasa estimate that as many as 70 percent of street children had been accused of sorcery in their homes before coming to live on the streets. One activist who advocates for assistance and protection of street children told us that there is no bigger factor in pushing children on to the streets today than accusations of sorcery.115

It is rare that children who live with both biological parents are accused of sorcery. In interviews we conducted with accused children, every one of them had lost one or both parents and had been living with extended family members who were facing extremely difficult economic problems. A Roman Catholic priest who shelters street children in Kinshasa conducted a survey of 630 children accused of sorcery in 2004. Of that number, only seventeen had both parents living.116 Children in the DRC who have lost one or both parents are traditionally taken into the care of stepmothers or stepfathers, grandparents, uncles and aunts, or older siblings. But numerous organizations that work with children told us that this tradition was being undermined as a growing number of families were being expected to care for their relatives’ children while at the same time facing increasing economic difficulties themselves. They told us that some families were simply unable to cope with the care of their relatives’ children, but stressed that sending children to the streets would be culturally unacceptable.

Accusations of sorcery, particularly by a religious leader, however, provided an excuse for guardians to chase children from their homes. The same Roman Catholic priest who conducted the survey of accused child sorcerers in Kinshasa told us, “I believe that for the most part, parents or guardians do not necessarily believe it is sorcery. They are just looking for a reason to get rid of the kids, the extra mouths they can’t feed. The children are the victims of larger social problems and the breakdown of the family.”117

Accusations of witchcraft and belief in the ability to cause harm to others through sorcery have existed in the DRC since before colonial rule, according to numerous Congolese we interviewed who are familiar with child sorcery cases. They reported that the major difference today is the age of the accused, and the number and location of the accusations. In the past, it was usually a widow or a woman who had remained single, not children, who were accused of sorcery. Accusations were usually made against rural women, who were made to live in relative isolation often at the edge of a village for fear that they would harm others. In the last fifteen years, however, children living in urban areas have become the primary targets of witchcraft allegations. Each week in the DRC, hundreds of children are accused of sorcery and endure abuse at the hands of their accusers––normally extended family members but, increasingly, self-proclaimed prophets or pastors as well.

In tandem with the increasing number of children accused of sorcery has been the creation of churches that specialize in the exorcism of evil spirits from the “possessed.” These églises de réveil or churches of revival combine prayers, fasting and abuse in “deliverance” ceremonies to rid children of “possession.” Approximately 2,000 churches perform “deliverance” ceremonies in Mbuji-Mayi and an even larger number operate in Kinshasa.118 Some of these churches and their leaders have attracted large followings and have become lucrative businesses. Although the deliverance ceremonies are reportedly performed for free, in reality, parents or guardians are strongly “encouraged” to make a financial donation or give a gift to the church in exchange for deliverance of a child. In addition, deliverance ceremonies are a way to attract new church members who may become regular contributors at Sunday services.119

Thousands of children in the DRC undergo “deliverance ceremonies” to rid them of “possession.”
© 2005 Marcus Bleasdale

Abuses in the home related to sorcery accusations

Children can be accused of sorcery for any number of reasons. The loss of a job, an illness or death in the family, or marital difficulties can lead parents or guardians to look to their children as the cause. Perceived “unusual” behavior in children, such as bed wetting, aggressive behavior, sleep walking, nightmares, or simply sharing food with neighboring children, can trigger sorcery accusations. Children who suffer from epilepsy, chronic illness, or mental illness can also be fingered. Once a child has been identified as a sorcerer, than he or she receives different treatment from other children in the family. They are sometimes made to eat their meals alone or sleep separately from the rest of the family. They can have food withheld or be given the least and last. They may be pulled out of school, made to do disproportionate amounts of domestic work, or be forced to work on the streets to earn their keep. Children accused of sorcery report particularly brutal behavior at the hands of their parents or guardians. They are beaten, whipped, or slapped in an attempt to rid them of the “possession” or to coerce them to confess to being a sorcerer. They are insulted, called derogatory names and made to feel less than human. Street children we interviewed about sorcery accusations expressed confusion and frustration about the accusations and the abusive treatment they received. Many expressed great sadness about the abuse by family members, and fear to return to their homes should reunification be possible.

Eleven-year-old Michael began living on the streets three years ago after he was forced from his home by his stepmother. Soon after he began living with his stepmother, she accused him of sorcery. He was forced to eat separately from the other children in the family and given smaller portions of food. He was not allowed to sit near his half-siblings and slept in a corner of the kitchen by himself. Michael told us that his stepmother insisted that this was necessary so he wouldn’t transmit the sorcery to his brothers and sisters. On several occasions he was beaten at night by his stepmother with the handle of a shovel on his hands and back so that he would confess to being “possessed.” He was told to leave home unless he turned over the physical items he used in conducting sorcery. Not knowing what to do, and of course not having such items, he left home when he was eight years old.120

Aubrey was twelve years old when he fled his home to escape abuse. After his parents died, he went to live with his older brother, his brother’s wife, and their children. He told us that his sister-in-law accused him of being responsible for the death of their youngest son, who died soon after his birth. She began treating Aubrey badly, not giving him the same amount of food as her own children. If he complained, she would slap him or beat him with the handle of a broom. She insulted him, calling him a sorcerer and a murderer. After she had convinced his brother that Aubrey was responsible for the death of their baby boy, Aubrey fled the house and began his life on the streets.121

We interviewed ten-year-old Albert at a center for vulnerable children supported by the Catholic Church. His mother died of tuberculosis and after her funeral he went to live with his father and his father’s second wife and children. According to Albert:

After my father left home on business, this is when the problem started. My half-brother, who lived with us, accused me of stealing food and practicing sorcery. We never had enough to eat, sometimes we ate only once a day and I was given less than the others. This is because my half-brother was the only one making money. He made sure that the others got food and clothes and I did not. He said I was a sorcerer and should leave. He would beat me with a large spoon that the mother would use to make fufu (cassava meal) to get me to leave…. I began spending more and more time away from the house at the compound of a church nearby. My brother found me there one day and beat me severely with his fists, telling me to leave the neighborhood. The pastor there told my brother to stop the beating, but seemed to believe him that I was a sorcerer and made me leave the church. I had no choice but to go to the streets.122

Abuses in churches

Parents or guardians who accuse children of witchcraft may send the child to a church for deliverance ceremonies organized by pastors or prophets. In the last fifteen years, self-proclaimed pastors and prophets have established numerous “churches of revival”123 that specialize in the deliverance of children from alleged possession. Many of these churches combine traditional Congolese beliefs and rituals with elements of Christianity.

The ceremonies that pastors perform range from simple prayers and singing to holding the children for several days at the churches, denying them food and water, and whipping or beating confessions out of them. Save the Children/UK has been active in attempting to change the behavior of the worst of these pastors. According to a Save the Children/UK project manager in Mbuji-Mayi, the most abusive pastors withhold food and water from children, whip or burn them to coerce their confessions, or pour salt water in their anuses or down their throats to purge the “evil” from their bodies.124 An organized group of pastors in Kinshasa which, through peer outreach, tries to change the behavior of abusive pastors confirmed these accusations. They additionally reported that sometimes children are tied up during their confinement at the churches and that in a few cases boys and girls have been sexually assaulted by members affiliated with the churches while in confinement.125

We interviewed several children who had undergone particularly brutal deliverance ceremonies. Twelve-year-old Brian never knew his real father but was accused by his stepfather of sorcery soon after his mother remarried. He told us that the accusations began the night after he wet his bed. In the following days his stepfather beat him, called him names, and later took him to a church for deliverance. Brian was not kept at the church at night, but had to come each day during a four-day period. He told us, “We were not allowed to eat or drink for three days [either at church or at home]. On the fourth day, the prophet held our hands over a candle, to get us to confess.” When it was Brian’s turn, he was told that he would be whipped if he didn’t confess. Weak from thirst and hunger, he admitted that he was a sorcerer so that he could leave the church.126

Malachi was only nine when he and his brother were brought by his stepfather to a deliverance ceremony. He told us that his stepfather brutally beat him and his brother in front of the pastor at the church. The pastor then agreed that Malachi and his brother were “possessed” and needed deliverance. Malachi told us only that his brother went through the painful ceremony, but refused to describe to us what had happened.127

Many of the children we talked with were unable to identify which church or pastor had performed the deliverance ceremony. One boy in Mbuji-Mayi, however, told us that his stepmother had brought him and his little brother to Prophet Kabuni Wa Lesa at the Charismatic Evangelical Center. The two boys were held for three days at the church and given no food or water, but were not otherwise physically abused. On the third day they were given some murky water, at which point his little brother began vomiting. His little brother’s expulsion of the water reportedly led the prophet to identify him as the source of sorcery in the family.128

Pastors or prophets who perform deliverance ceremonies blend elements of Christianity with Congolese traditions and rituals.
© 2005 Marcus Bleasdale

In an interview with Human Rights Watch, Prophet Kabuni told us that the vast majority of his clients at the deliverance ceremonies were children. He said that he was well known in the community as a successful diviner of sorcery, and that because of his reputation he had scores of children brought to him each week. He told us that it was necessary to withhold food and water from everyone undergoing deliverance ceremonies to decrease the evil power that held those who were possessed. When questioned about the practice and the harm this could cause a child, he replied that there had never been a death at his church and that they do not withhold food and water from young children––defined by him as less than four years old.129

After the accusations

Some children who undergo these ceremonies are reunified with their family members who believe that the spirits have been exorcised. Some families, though, appear unconvinced that the ceremony was successful. They may accept the child initially and wait to see whether another perceived evil occurs and if so, throw the child out. In other cases, children returning from the churches are immediately made to leave the home, whether or not the ceremony was deemed successful by the pastors.

According to a Roman Catholic priest working with street children in Kinshasa, many pastors who perform these ceremonies are most concerned with the wishes of the adults who bring the child in for deliverance. If they appear not to want the child to return, then the pastor may advise the parent or guardian not to take the child back, or may suggest the boy or girl may need to return to the church for further consultations.130 A prophet who “delivers” children in Kinshasa, confirmed that one challenge was reunifying children with their families after performing a ceremony. He told us, “Our biggest problem is that children come here, we do the service, but then the parents do not want the children back. This is especially true in cases where the child has ‘eaten’131 someone in the family. We try to convince the parents where we can.”132

Twelve-year-old Brian, who was abused during a deliverance ceremony, told us:

After I confessed to being a sorcerer, I didn’t have to go back to the church. But things at home got worse. My stepfather never believed that the prophet was successful. He would beat me when he saw me. Even my mother began to believe I was a sorcerer. One time when I was sleeping, she poured petrol into my ears.133 Another time, she brought me to a section of town I didn’t know and abandoned me there. I eventually found my way home but was not welcomed into the house. I decided at that point it was better to live on the streets.134

Activists who try to reunify street children with their families identified cases of children accused of sorcery as being the most difficult and least likely to succeed. Guardians or family members often refuse to listen to social workers or accept a child back once he or she has left the home. For these activists, the general failure to reunify children accused of sorcery makes successful prevention all the more important, but they told us that despite the efforts of some nongovernmental organizations, the government was doing very little to deter the abuse.

Small children at a deliverance ceremony. During the ceremony, children’s eyes and ears are blocked to disrupt the transmission of “sorcery.”
© 2005 Marcus Bleasdale

The police, judicial investigators and government officials rarely intervene in cases of child sorcery accusations and physical abuse in homes or in churches. Police personnel we interviewed claimed that cases of physical abuse were not generally brought to their attention since it was children who would have to make the accusations.135 Judges in the Courts of Peace in Mbuji-Mayi and Lubumbashi were aware of only a few cases of parents or guardians charged with physical abuse, and none related to accusations of sorcery.136 For abusive pastors and prophets, little has been done to curb their practices. In Mbuji-Mayi, Congolese human rights organizations, judicial personnel, and the police themselves knew of no case where a pastor or church had been investigated for abusing children. In Kinshasa in 2004, the then Minister of Social Affairs, at the insistence of children’s rights groups, reportedly led an investigation into a case where church leaders were abusing children. The pastor was arrested and the church temporarily closed, but the pastor was never brought to justice.137 Officials in both the Ministries of Justice and Social Affairs agreed that more needed to be done to curb abusive practices by both parents and pastors, particularly because such abuse is expressly prohibited and punishable by law under the new constitution.138


The ongoing HIV/AIDS epidemic is increasing both the number of children who are orphaned, and the accusations of child sorcery. The estimated national HIV/AIDS prevalence rate is 4.2 percent in the DRC, lower than many countries in eastern and southern Africa, yet some one million Congolese children have been orphaned by the epidemic.139 Orphaned children are often taken in by extended family members who may not be able to properly care for them. These children are less likely to go to school, more likely to be working in the streets to support their families, and face other considerable disadvantages in comparison with other children.140 Additionally, stigma, discrimination against people living with or affected by AIDS, and misinformation about the disease are widespread in the DRC.

Many Congolese appear to believe that HIV/AIDS can be spread through sorcery. In the worst instances we documented, family members blamed surviving children for causing the death of their parents from AIDS through sorcery. For example, fifteen-year-old Timothy, whose parents both died of complications related to AIDS in 1995, has been living in an orphanage for almost ten years. Following his parent’s deaths, he briefly lived with his older brothers and sisters, but they accused him of sorcery, transmitting the virus to his parents, and “eating” them. He was shunned by his siblings, made to stay outside of their home, and not given proper care. A neighbor who noticed his wretched state eventually intervened and placed him in an orphanage.141

Many pastors and prophets who specialize in child “deliverance” reinforce the message that children can transmit the virus to family members through sorcery. They may explain to parents or guardians that a child is responsible for spreading the disease to a family member through witchcraft in an effort to convince them to allow the child to undergo deliverance at the church. When questioned about HIV/AIDS, a prophet in Mbuji-Mayi told us, “Child sorcerers have the power to transmit any disease, including AIDS, to their family members. AIDS is a mysterious disease that is used as a weapon by those who practice witchcraft.”142 HIV/AIDS awareness and prevention campaigns stressing ABC (Abstinence, Be faithful, and use Condoms) have to date failed to refute the idea that HIV can be transmitted through sorcery, and have done nothing to address the abuses experienced by children or to reduce their vulnerability.143

The director of the Youth Movement for Excellence, a Kinshasa-based organization that cares for street children and widows, told us that nearly half of the children they care for are affected by HIV/AIDS. Many of those children have been accused of sorcery and held responsible for the deaths of their parents or siblings due to complications from HIV/AIDS. Accused children can be physically and emotionally abused by their caregivers and are either forced from their homes or leave the house on their own because of the abuse.144

Worse off still are children who are themselves HIV positive and are made to believe they are responsible for their illness and for the deaths of family members. We interviewed one boy and one girl, both infected with HIV, who, in place of care and treatment, were physically abused by their family members, accused of being sorcerers, and thrown out of their homes. One twelve-year-old boy who has been living with HIV for over a year said that because he was often sick, his paternal uncle accused him of being a sorcerer and held him responsible for the death of his parents who had died of AIDS. His food and care were withheld and he was forced from his home. A social worker familiar with the case told us that in discussions with family members, the paternal uncle told him that he had refused to accept that his nephew was HIV positive, and instead insisted that he was possessed, which for him explained the boy’s illness. The uncle told the social worker that the boy had put a spell on the parents which caused their sickness and eventual death, and that he believed that if he agreed to take the boy back, a similar fate awaited other family members.145

A street boy sleeping in a shelter in Kinshasa. © 2005 Marcus Bleasdale

Some children orphaned by AIDS and later accused by family members of sorcery are also victims of disinheritance and property grabbing by their relatives. Several children orphaned by AIDS and later accused of sorcery by their aunts or uncles told us that soon after the property of their deceased parents had been divided or sold, they were accused of sorcery and abused. Paul, an orphan living on the streets of Kinshasa, said that when his parent’s died from complications due to AIDS, his paternal uncle sold his parents’ house and refused to care for him and his siblings. His uncle accused them of sorcery, refused to properly feed and clothe them or pay for their schooling, and kept the money from the sale of the property as well as other valuables that belonged to their parents.146 Twelve-year-old Simon told us that his father had several parcels of land that he rented out for use by other farmers. When his father died from AIDS, his uncles divided up the land and sold it. Like Paul, Simon was accused of sorcery and thrown out of an uncle’s house where he had been living after the death of his parents.147 An official in the Division of Social Affairs in Kinshasa has observed a link between cases of children orphaned by AIDS, accusations of sorcery by relatives, and property grabbing of these children’s parents’ valuables. She told us that even though children under Congolese law are able to inherit their parents’ property, very few children know this right or are able to effectively challenge family members in court.148


Numerous officials and children we interviewed for this report stressed that the inability of parents or guardians to pay school fees and other related costs of primary education was one reason that children began spending time in the streets. The Minister of Social Affairs, M. Laurent Otete Omanga, told us that, “Many parents can not pay for their children’s education. These children stay at home with nothing to do and soon go out on the streets looking for work or amusement. They can easily be exploited by adults who pay them very little, often for very hard work. Or, they begin to associate with children who have lived on the streets for some time. They may begin drinking alcohol, using drugs and committing crimes. Once they are used to life on the streets, they leave home and join criminal street gangs.”149

Like many of the street children we interviewed, Peter, in Lubumbashi, told us that once he dropped out of school, he began exploring life on the streets. “I had to leave school after I finished the third grade. My parents could no longer afford the fees, so I started coming to the streets to look for something to do. Life here on the streets is hard, there is never enough to eat and I am hungry. I would like to return to school and continue my studies.”150 Similarly another street boy, Benjamin, in Kinshasa, told us that after his mother died, his father stopped paying for his schooling. He only finished his fourth year of primary school. With nothing else to do, he began working on the streets, selling matches and water.151

A children’s rights activist in Mbuji-Mayi who has done research on abusive forms of child labor around mining activities believes that lack of schooling for many Congolese children is what drives them into child labor and eventually onto the streets. He told us that many parents and guardians in the country are unable to afford the prohibitively high cost of schooling. In the DRC, a parent or guardian must pay several dollars a month to send a child to primary school and also supply a uniform and school materials––costs beyond the means of many families who survive on one meal a day. For this activist, the inability of adults to pay for school leads their children to begin working at young ages in activities around the mines. He explained that as some children begin to receive small amounts of money for their labor, they may not want to share it with their family members. As they begin spending more and more time away from home, they become habituated to the street and can become full-time street children.152

Albert is an orphan living on the streets of Mbuji-Mayi. He told us that upon the death of his parents he moved in with his older sister and her husband. He said that his brother-in-law was abusive, would beat him, and refused to pay for his schooling. He decided to seek work in the mines to bring in income for the family. During several months of working and sharing his meager salary with his family the abuse by his brother-in-law continued. He finally decided that he would manage on his own and began living on the streets outside of town.153

After years of warfare, economic decline, and limited to nonexistent state services, providing education for Congolese children, much less free primary education, remains a serious challenge for the government. Nevertheless, it must be recognized that the lack of educational opportunities for children in the DRC drives thousands of children into child labor each year, including hazardous and illegal child labor, and for some children, into the streets. The new constitution, adopted by the National Assembly in 2005 and overwhelmingly approved by voters in 2006, makes clear in article 42 that primary education must be obligatory and free in public schools.154 The government, therefore, should make every effort to provide education to the maximum number of children possible and create a national strategy to progressively reduce and eliminate school fees and related costs of education that prevent poor children from going to school.

[111] Human Rights Watch interviews with the president of the Tribunal of Peace, Lubumbashi, September 19, 2005, and with the president of the Tribunal of Peace, Mbuji-Mayi, September 26, 2005.

[112] Human Rights Watch interview with Jacques, twelve, Lubumbashi, September 18, 2005.

[113] Human Rights Watch interview with Aaron, Kinshasa, October 1, 2005.

[114] Human Rights Watch interview with Isaac, fourteen, Goma, September 13, 2005.

[115] Human Rights Watch interview with Remy Mafu Sasa, Kinshasa, September 28, 2005.

[116] Human Rights Watch interview with Pere Zibi, ORPER center, Kinshasa, September 29, 2005.

[117] Ibid.

[118] Human Rights Watch interview with Jean Valea, Save the Children-UK, Mbuji-Mayi, September 22, 2005.

[119] For more information on street children and accusations of child sorcery, see: Javier Aguilar Molina, The Invention of Child Witches in the Democratic Republic of Congo Social Cleansing, Religious Commerce and the Difficulties of Being a Parent in an Urban Culture, Summary of the research and experiences of Save the Children’s 2003-2005 programme funded by USAID, 2006; and Filip de Boeck, “On Being Shege in Kinshasa: Children, the Occult, and the Street,” in Theodore Trefon ed. Reinventing Order in the Congo. How People Respond to State Failure in Kinshasa (London and New York: Zed Books, 2004), pp. 155-173.

[120] Human Rights Watch interview with Michael, Mbuji-Mayi, September 23, 2005.

[121] Human Rights Watch interview with Aubrey, fourteen, Kinshasa, September 30, 2005.

[122] Human Rights Watch interview with Albert, Mbuji-Mayi, September 23, 2005.

[123] According to a group of pastors we interviewed, the majority of deliverance ceremonies take place in churches of revival (églises de réveil); other exorcism ceremonies are conducted in churches of black magic (églises de noir), churches of healing (églises de guerir), or Christian churches.

[124] Human Rights Watch interview with Jean Valea, Save the Children/UK, Mbuji-Mayi, September 22, 2005.

[125] Human Rights Watch interview with Reverend Gode and other pastors, Kinshasa, October 3, 2005.

[126] Human Rights Watch interview with Brian, Kinshasa, September 30, 2005.

[127] Human Rights Watch interview with Malachi, eleven, Kinshasa, October 1, 2005.

[128] Human Rights Watch interview with Francis, nine, Mbuji-Mayi, September 25, 2005.

[129] Human Rights Watch interview with Kabuni Wa Lesa, Charismatic Evangelical Center, Mbuji-Mayi, September 27, 2005.

[130] Human Rights Watch interview with a priest, Kinshasa, September 29, 2005.

[131] Children or adults who are blamed for the death of another person were often described as having “eaten” them, apparently referring to their soul.

[132] Human Rights Watch interview with Prophet Bisombolo, Eglise Viaka, Kinshasa, October 3, 2005.

[133] Children who have undergone “deliverance” ceremonies, pastors who perform them, and child welfare activists, all told us that blocking or covering the eyes and ears of a child is an integral part of deliverance ceremonies. It reportedly interrupts visual or audio communication from “evil spirits” and helps the message from the deliverer to be received.

[134] Human Rights Watch interview with Brian, Kinshasa, September 30, 2005.

[135] Human Rights Watch interviews with police, Goma, September 14, 2005, and Mbuji-Mayi, September 27, 2005.

[136] Human Rights Watch interviews, Lubumbashi, September 19, 2005, and Mbuji-Mayi, September 26, 2005.

[137] Human Rights Watch interview with officials in the Ministry of Justice, Kinshasa, September 30, 2005.

[138] Article 41 of the Constitution of the Democratic Republic of Congo, 2005. Article 41 states that, “the abandonment and mistreatment of children especially pedophilia, sexual abuse as well as accusations of sorcery are prohibited and punishable by law.”

[139] Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS) and World Health Organization (WHO), Epidemiological Fact Sheets on HIV/AIDS and Sexually Transmitted Infections: Democratic Republic of Congo (2004 Update), p. 2.

[140] Human Rights Watch, “Letting Them Fail: Government Neglect and the Right to Education for Children Affected by AIDS,” A Human Rights Watch Report, vol. 17, no. 13(A), October 2005, [online],

[141] Human Rights Watch interview with Timothy, Kinshasa, October 1, 2005.

[142] Human Rights Watch interview with Pastor Kabuni Wa Lesa, Mbuji-Mayi, September 27, 2005.

[143] Human Rights Watch interview, Kinshasa, September 29-30, 2005.

[144] Human Rights Watch interview with John Lisumba, Kinshasa, September 29, 2005.

[145] Human Rights Watch interview with a social worker, Mbuji-Mayi, September 23, 2005.

[146] Human Rights Watch interview with Paul, twelve, Kinshasa, September 30, 2005.

[147] Human Rights Watch interview with Simon, Mbuji-Mayi, September 23, 2005.

[148] Human Rights Watch interview with official in the Division of Social Affairs, Kinshasa, September 29, 2005.

[149] Human Rights Watch interview with the Minister of Social Affairs, Kinshasa, September 29, 2005.

[150] Human Rights Watch interview with Peter, fifteen, Lubumbashi, September 16, 2005.

[151] Human Rights Watch interview with Benjamin, seventeen, Kinshasa, October 1, 2005.

[152] Human Rights Watch interview with M. Chimanga, Mbuji-Mayi, September 22, 2005.

[153] Human Rights Watch interview with Albert, twelve, Chimuna village, September 24, 2005.

[154] Article 42 of the Constitution of the Democratic Republic of Congo, 2005.